Beyond the Questions: A Strategic Approach to Voir Dire
By Judge Sherine Thomas | November 15, 2026

Attorneys often approach voir dire as an afterthought to their case. The reality is that one of the most important parts of voir dire happens before anyone enters the courtroom. Before beginning, the attorney should determine what they are trying to accomplish both during voir dire and with each question.

As you approach the voir dire process, it may be helpful to think about your first day of high school. When a teacher asks a question of the class, some students will immediately raise their hands to answer, but most students are not willing to participate right away. Attorneys should expect a similar dynamic during voir dire. Initially, the panel may hesitate to speak. The task of eliciting candid participation from members of the venire falls upon the attorney. The attorney not only needs to ask questions that elicit meaningful responses but also needs to create an environment conducive to candid and meaningful participation.

These are some practical tips to make voir dire more productive.

Have a Clear Objective for Your Questions

Like most phases of trial, every question should serve a function.

Often, the goal is to gather information about the panel, use the panel’s responses to educate other jurors about a particular issue or way of thinking, identify issues that may support a challenge for cause, or assist in the exercise of a peremptory strike.

Before asking a question, consider: What am I trying to learn from this question? Will the answer give me information I can use? What will I do with the answer?

Generally, questions that require only a “yes” or “no” answer provide a starting point rather than a complete answer. Attorneys often fail to explore the reason behind the response. Potential jurors may have difficulty agreeing with a broad generalization but may readily agree with a more specific premise.

For example, in a divorce case, an attorney might ask, “Do you agree that it is okay for one spouse to have a separate account for money?” (Because, in Texas and Georgia, juries decide divorce cases!) Many potential jurors may agree, but their agreement may depend on whether there is transparency between the spouses and what the parties agreed to during the marriage. The follow-up is what matters. Questions that allow potential jurors to make those distinctions can produce more productive answers. Consider a follow-up question or a different question all together, such as a question that addresses whether there are circumstances in which it is appropriate for one spouse to have a separate account.

Attorneys often ask questions such as:

  • Do you agree?
  • Who believes this?
  • Who disagrees?

Remember those answers should only be a stepping off point. The attorney should use the response to determine why the panel member holds that position. Ask follow-up questions like “Why do you feel that way?” or “Would you explain?”

Scale questions can also be useful:

  • Who strongly agrees with the following statement?
  • Who agrees?
  • Who disagrees?
  • Who strongly disagrees?

Even with these types of questions, it is necessary to move beyond the initial response and explore the reasoning behind it.

Well-designed questions can create an environment in which panel members respond to and learn from one another. The attorney can use questions to identify areas of agreement, disagreement, and uncertainty within the panel.

Counsel should also incorporate important words and concepts from the case into voir dire questions. Those words can become part of the jury's vocabulary as the trial progresses.

Ultimately, effective voir dire is not simply a process of asking questions and recording answers. It is an opportunity to learn about the panel, identify potential juror issues, educate the jury, begin developing the case’s themes, and establish a relationship with the people who may ultimately decide the case.

Use Voir Dire to Establish a Relationship With the Panel

Where appropriate, attorneys can share limited personal experiences as examples of why they may not be a good juror for the case at hand. Personal experiences can help humanize the attorney and make panel members more comfortable participating in the process.

Voir dire should not become about the attorney. Rather, sharing an attorney’s personal experiences may encourage discussion and provide the panel with a way to understand why certain feelings or experiences might make someone a less-than-ideal juror.

For example, an attorney handling a divorce case involving primary custody might share that being raised by a single mother with an uninvolved father could affect the attorney's ability to be objective if they were a juror in the case. The purpose would not be to tell the attorney's story, but to illustrate how personal experiences can shape a person's perspective and potentially create bias. By being appropriately vulnerable, the attorney can also create a relationship with the panel and encourage jurors to consider their own experiences.

Humor can also be used carefully to illustrate bias. Attorneys can use a lighthearted example to show how natural divides can arise and how a person might not be a good juror for a particular matter. For example, an attorney might say, “I couldn't be a good judge for a chili cook-off because where I'm from, there is no such thing as beans in chili.” Or, “I couldn’t judge a pizza competition if pineapple were an ingredient.”

The particular story the attorney chooses is of little consequence. The point is that people can hold strong opinions about seemingly ordinary subjects based on their experiences and beliefs, and those beliefs may make them less appropriate for a particular jury.

These examples humanize the attorney and give the panel permission to acknowledge biases that might otherwise be difficult to discuss. Used appropriately, examples like these can encourage panel members to recognize and discuss their own biases.

Get Assistance and Take Good Notes

Whenever possible, have someone assist with the voir dire process. It is difficult to ask questions, listen carefully to the answers, formulate follow-up questions, observe the panel, and keep detailed notes at the same time

Successful voir dire requires the attorney to listen closely to responses and follow up appropriately. Some questions may elicit multiple responses, and the attorney needs a reliable way to keep track of them.

Good notes are critical. Write down not only the substance of a panel member's answer but also important phrases used by the panel member. It can also be helpful to note nonverbal cues and other observations, provided those observations are made carefully and accurately.

Detailed notes can assist with effective follow-up questions and may become important if a party later seeks to challenge a panel member for cause or defend against a Batson challenge.

Batson v. Kentucky, 476 U.S. 79 (1986), established that using peremptory challenges to exclude prospective jurors because of race violates the Equal Protection Clause. The Supreme Court of the United States subsequently extended constitutional protection against discriminatory peremptory strikes to gender, and the principles have been applied in civil as well as criminal cases.

A Batson challenge generally involves a three-step process. First, the party objecting to the strike must make a prima facie showing of discriminatory purpose. If that showing is made, the burden of production shifts to the party exercising the strike to provide a race-neutral—or otherwise legally permissible—explanation. The objecting party then has an opportunity to challenge that explanation, and the trial court determines whether purposeful discrimination has been established. The ultimate burden of persuasion remains with the party challenging the strike.

For that reason, good voir dire notes can be particularly important. They may allow counsel to identify inconsistencies between a panel member's answers and the stated reason for a peremptory strike and to preserve the record concerning the circumstances surrounding the strike.

Do Not Forget to Ask Questions of the Entire Panel

Attorneys often focus on the first few rows of the venire panel—that can be a mistake.

After all strikes have been exercised, the jury may ultimately be selected from members sitting in the back rows—jurors about whom counsel has learned very little. Questions should be directed to the entire panel at some point. Counsel should make an effort to learn something about every potential juror who could ultimately be seated. One technique is to ask questions by row number.

Acknowledge Truthful and Candid Answers

To encourage candid and meaningful participation, attorneys should acknowledge thoughtful and honest responses—even when those responses are not helpful to the client's position.

When a panel member provides a difficult or unexpected answer, a simple acknowledgment can encourage others to speak honestly. Simply acknowledge the response with "Thank you for being candid."

The attorney does not have to agree with the response. The goal is to create an environment in which panel members feel comfortable providing honest answers rather than giving the answer they believe the attorney or court wants to hear.

An effective voir dire begins with careful preparation before entering the courtroom and becomes more effective when connecting with potential panelists through anecdotes, thoughtful follow-ups, and personal connections. These tips can set your trial up for success before a single exhibit is presented.

Judge Sherine E. Thomas is the presiding judge of the 353rd District Court of Travis County, Texas. She is a past president of the Robert W. Calvert American Inn of Court in Austin, Texas, and a member of the Editorial Board for The Bencher.

© 2026 Judge Sherine Thomas. This article was originally published in The Bencher, the online magazine of the American Inns of Court. This article, in full or in part, may not be copied, reprinted, distributed, or stored electronically in any form without the written consent of the American Inns of Court.